How to Manage Your First Rental Property

How to Manage Your First Rental Property


At New Western, our vision is a world where every real estate transaction is simple, certain, and satisfying. Therefore, we promote strict editorial integrity in each of our posts.

Owning rental properties can be a lucrative investment, but managing them can be a challenge, especially if it’s your first. As a landlord, you are responsible for finding the right tenants, setting rent prices, handling lease agreements, and maintaining your property. In this guide, we’ll take a closer look at each of these areas and provide you with tips on how to effectively manage your rental properties.

Setting Rent Prices for Your Property

As a landlord or property owner, one of the most important decisions you will make is setting the rent price for your property. A well-priced rental property can attract high-quality tenants and maximize your income, while an overpriced or underpriced property can lead to vacancies and financial losses.

  • Conduct a local market analysis

Conducting a proper market analysis for your specific property involves researching the local rental market to determine the average rent prices for properties that are similar to yours in terms of location, size, and amenities. You can do this by browsing online rental listings, checking local newspapers and classifieds, and speaking with other landlords or property managers in your area.

As you do those things, look at the number of properties available, the prices they are charging, and the length of time they have been on the market. This will give you an idea of the demand for similar rental properties in your area and the price range that tenants are willing to pay.

  • Consider your property’s unique features

While market analysis is an important first step, it’s also important to consider the unique features of your property. Does it have a prime location, modern appliances, or a large backyard? These features may justify a higher rent price than similar properties in the area.

  • Determine your expenses

Another important factor to consider is your expenses. This includes mortgage payments, property taxes, maintenance costs, marketing, and any other expenses related to owning and managing the property. Ideally, your rental income should cover all of these expenses and provide you with a reasonable profit left over.

  • Use a rent calculator

A useful tool that you’ll want to leverage is a rent calculator. While many will have slight differences in the layout and exact details you’ll need to enter, the end result should be an estimate of what you should or could charge to rent your property. The free online tools generally take into account your cost, market conditions, location, size, and sometimes other factors to provide an estimate of the rent price that is appropriate for your property. It’s important to note that these calculators are just tools to give you information and help you break down the numbers. There are mitigating factors that won’t fit into any rent calculator. Ultimately, you need to consider all the information available be the one who decides what to charge. Free rent calculators can be found by simply searching online, and can be a helpful starting point when setting rent prices.  

  • Adjust rent prices based on demand

It’s important to stay flexible when setting rent prices, and to adjust them based on demand. If you are having difficulty finding tenants, you may need to lower your rent prices to make your property more competitive. Conversely, if you have a lot of interested tenants, you may be able to increase your rent prices to maximize your income.

  • Be aware of rent control laws

Rent control laws are in place in some cities and states, and limit the amount that landlords can increase rent prices each year. While most places don’t have these laws, and simply let the market decide the price, it’s important to be aware of these laws and to follow them to avoid legal issues and financial penalties.


Screening Tenants

The success of your rental property business largely depends on the tenants you choose. Ensuring that you have decent tenants can help ensure that your property is well-maintained, the rent is paid on time, and that you have a positive relationship with the people living in your rental home. In order to find the right tenants for your property, you need to have a screening system in place. This can include checking their credit score, rental history, personal references, and employment status. You could also conduct a background check to see that they have a clean criminal record, or at least one that doesn’t cross the line of what you’re comfortable with.

In addition to the checks mentioned above, you can also have a phone or video call to give them a brief interview. You don’t hire someone for a job without interviewing them, and the same process on an abbreviated level can help you find the right tenant. This can give you a better understanding of who they are as a person. It’s important to set clear tenant criteria and stick to them to ensure that you find the right individuals for your property.


Handling Lease Agreements

As a landlord, it is essential to have a comprehensive understanding of how to handle residential lease agreements. The lease agreement is a legal contract between the landlord and the tenant, which outlines the terms and conditions of renting a residential property. This article will provide valuable insights on how to handle residential lease agreements as a landlord, including the essential components of a lease agreement, how to draft a lease agreement, and how to handle lease violations.

Introduction to Residential Lease Agreements

  1. Residential lease agreements are legally binding contracts that dictate the terms and conditions of renting a residential property. The lease agreement outlines the responsibilities of the landlord and the tenant, including rent payments, security deposits, maintenance responsibilities, and other important details.

Essential Components of a Lease Agreement

  1. A lease agreement should contain essential components such as:
  • Names of the landlord and tenant
  • Address of the rental property
  • Lease term and rent amount
  • Security deposit amount and terms of refund
  • Late payment fees and grace periods
  • Maintenance responsibilities of the landlord and tenant
  • Rules and regulations for the property
  • Renewal and termination clauses

Drafting a Lease Agreement

  1. When drafting a lease agreement, landlords should consider several factors, including:
  • Consultation with an attorney to ensure compliance with relevant laws and regulations
  • Clear and concise language to avoid any misunderstandings or confusion
  • Use of formal language to convey the seriousness of the agreement
  • Inclusion of relevant provisions that protect the landlord’s interests, such as late payment fees and security deposits
  • Explanation of the tenant’s obligations, such as maintaining the property and not damaging it

Handling Lease Violations

  1. Lease violations can occur when tenants fail to meet the terms and conditions outlined in the lease agreement. As a landlord, it is essential to handle lease violations promptly and professionally. The steps to handle lease violations include:
  • Sending a written notice to the tenant outlining the violation
  • Giving the tenant a reasonable timeframe to remedy the situation
  • Following up with the tenant to ensure compliance
  • Taking legal action if the tenant fails to remedy the situation

Repairs and Maintenance

As a residential landlord, it is your responsibility to ensure that your property is in good condition and properly maintained. Failure to do so can result in unhappy tenants, legal disputes, and costly repairs down the line. Therefore, it is essential to have a clear plan in place for handling repairs and maintenance. Here are some tips to help you manage this aspect of your role as a residential landlord:

  1. Conduct Regular Inspections

It’s essential to conduct regular inspections of your property to identify any maintenance issues before they become major problems. Schedule annual inspections, and encourage tenants to report any problems as soon as they arise. This will help you stay on top of repairs and prevent small problems from turning into more significant issues.

  1. Prioritize Repairs

When repairs are necessary, it’s crucial to prioritize them according to their urgency. Address issues that pose a safety risk, such as electrical or plumbing problems, first. Then, address other problems that could negatively impact your tenant’s quality of life, such as a broken refrigerator or a leaky roof.

  1. Hire Qualified Professionals

It’s essential to hire qualified professionals to handle repairs and maintenance tasks, particularly those that involve electrical or plumbing systems. Ensure that you work with licensed contractors who have a good reputation for quality work. This will help you avoid costly mistakes and ensure that your property remains in excellent condition.

  1. Communicate with Tenants

Effective communication is crucial when it comes to repairs and maintenance. Keep your tenants informed about any scheduled repairs or maintenance work and provide them with clear instructions on how to prepare for the work. Respond to tenant requests promptly and keep them informed about the status of any repairs or maintenance work.

  1. Set Up a Maintenance Fund

It’s essential to set aside money for repairs and maintenance. Consider setting up a maintenance fund to cover the cost of repairs and ensure that you have the necessary funds available when you need them. This can help you avoid unexpected expenses and ensure that you can address maintenance issues promptly.

Marketing Your Rental Property

To attract the right tenants, you need to market your rental property effectively. This includes creating an appealing listing that showcases the best features of your property. You should also use online rental platforms to reach a wider audience. Social media can also be a powerful tool for marketing your rental property.

In addition to online marketing, you can also use traditional marketing methods such as flyers, signs, networking, and word of mouth. It’s important to be proactive in marketing your property to ensure that you attract the right tenants and stay competitive in the rental market.

Read our post on how to effectively market your rental property to get more in depth expert advice on this topic.

Working with Professionals to Help Manage Your Rental Home

Managing a rental property can be time-consuming. And if it’s your first rental property, it can also come with a steep learning curve in various areas where you might little or no experience. You may consider working with professionals to help you manage everything effectively. The most obvious is hiring a property manager. They can help lighten the load and ensure your investment is managed effectively. There are individuals, small local companies, and larger corporations that offer this service with varying levels of detail to what they offer. All of this, of course, comes at a price. So you need to do the math to make sure that the time saved and valued added is worth the expense.

In addition to property managers, several other professionals can help landlords manage their rental properties more effectively:

  • Real Estate Agent: Real estate agents can assist in marketing your rental property, attracting potential tenants, and negotiating lease agreements. They have extensive knowledge of the local rental market and can help you set competitive rental rates.
  • Attorney: A real estate attorney can help you navigate the legal aspects of property management, such as drafting lease agreements, handling eviction proceedings, and ensuring compliance with local regulations and laws.
  • Accountant: A professional accountant can help you manage the financial aspects of your rental properties, such as tax planning, bookkeeping, and budgeting. They can also help you maximize tax deductions and ensure you comply with relevant tax laws.
  • Insurance Agent: An insurance agent can help you determine the appropriate coverage for your rental property and ensure you are adequately protected against potential risks and liabilities.
  • Maintenance and Repair Professionals: Building relationships with reliable contractors, plumbers, electricians, and other service providers can help you address maintenance and repair issues promptly and efficiently. A well-maintained property is more likely to attract and retain quality tenants.
  • Pest Control Professionals: Regular pest control inspections and treatments can prevent infestations, protect your property from damage, and create a more comfortable living environment for your tenants.
  • Landscaping Professionals: A professional landscaper can help maintain the curb appeal of your rental property, which can attract better tenants and potentially increase your property’s value.
  • Property Inspector: Property inspectors can conduct regular inspections of your rental property, identifying potential issues and recommending necessary repairs or improvements.
  • Security Professionals: If your rental property is located in an area with security concerns, you may want to work with security professionals to ensure the safety of your tenants and property. This could involve installing security systems, surveillance cameras, or hiring a security patrol service. If security is of concern in the area, implementing these measures could also give you an advantage over other rental properties, allowing you to charge more per month.

By working with these professionals, you can streamline the property management process, ensure compliance with laws and regulations, and create a more attractive and profitable rental property. In most situations, you probably wouldn’t want to hire all of these at once when you first acquire a rental property. But it is wise to create a list of trusted professionals in each of these areas so that you can turn to them as needed.


Managing rental properties can be quite the undertaking, but with the right know-how and a little bit of elbow grease, it can also be quite rewarding. By keeping an eye on all the different aspects of your business – from screening tenants to marketing your property – you’ll be better equipped to ensure that everything runs smoothly. Remember, at the end of the day, a well-maintained property with happy tenants means a profitable investment for you. So keep these tips in mind, stay diligent, and here’s to a successful rental property business!

Disclaimer: The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only.