Find Investment Properties in Indianapolis, IN

Join the New Western Marketplace for investment grade opportunities.

Get access to our curated inventory of investor friendly properties


Indianapolis, IN
Housing market at a Glance.

With the Indy 500, Colts football, and Monument Circle–Idianapolis has a robust and diversified economy with people moving to the city to work for Eli Lilly and Salesforce. With more affordable housing the many larger cities in the U.S, the city has experienced steady growth and appreciation. More residents own homes then rent but with an affordable cost of living and rising rent rates, Indianapolis is a viable city for an investor to build a rental portfolio.

Indiana laws tend to be more favorable to landlords and the city offers a variety of neighborhoods, each with its own character and price point. Investors can target specific areas that suit their investment goals, such as single-family homes in growing suburbs, student housing near universities, or revitalized inner-city areas with high growth potential.

The stats and trends you need if you’re planning to put a flip on the market or purchase rental investment properties near Indianapolis, IN. 

Median Sale Price
% YoY

Credit: US Census Bureau, Redfin

Get in touch with a New Western agent at the Indianapolis, IN office, located at:

127 E Michigan St,, Suite 400
Indianapolis, Indiana 46204

New Western is a real estate investment marketplace with exclusive inventory for investors, a solution for sellers, and a tool for agents and brokers. Our office is located in the heart of downtown Indianapolis conveniently just west of I-70 at 127 E Michigan St, Suite 400, Indianapolis, IN 46204. Reach out if you are an investor looking to buy a property, a homeowner who needs to sell, or a real estate agent with a difficult listing in the Indianapolis area. We are licensed agents and experts in your market. We’ve got the largest private source of investment properties in the nation—call us to see what deals we have in the greater Indianapolis area.

Connect with our local Facebook community

Join the private Indianapolis, IN real estate investment Facebook group created for real estate investors, wholesalers, agents, Realtors, lenders, fix-and-flippers, rehabbers, interior designers, and contractors.

Join Facebook Group

Meet us in person at the next investor happy hour

Our events are a little bit different. There are no classroom presentations, get-rich-quick gurus, or sales pitches. Just real people, real connections, and no bull. We hope you'll come to enjoy a bite, grab a drink, and make connections with other like-minded real estate professionals.

Upcoming Events

REI on Tap | Columbus

Mon, June 24 - 5:30 pmHigh Bank Distillery

REI on Tap | Orlando

Tue, June 25 - 5:30 pmAmerican Social Orlando

REI on Tap | Austin

Wed, June 26 - 5:30 pmHold Out Brewing

REI on Tap | Greenville

Wed, June 26 - 6:00 pmSouthernside Brewing Co.

REI on Tap | Salt Lake City

Thu, July 25 - 5:30 pmSquatters Pub Brewery

How to get access and
join the Indianapolis, IN
New Western Marketplace


Submit The Form

A licensed, local Indianapolis, IN New Western agent will reach out to learn about your investment goals and discuss Indianapolis, IN opportunities.


Gain Access

To our curated Indianapolis, IN real estate investment marketplace, find a deal, and connect with the Indianapolis, IN New Western agent.


Choose a Property

To purchase, walkthrough, and close with the local Indianapolis, IN New Western agent.


Build a Relationship

With New Western in Indianapolis, IN and do more deals with investor-focused real estate experts in the Indianapolis, IN real estate market.

Why New Western?

You'll find investment properties for sale near you

More Indianapolis, IN Investment Properties

As a real estate investment marketplace, New Western offers a vast inventory of curated Indianapolis, IN properties you won’t find anywhere else.

Knowledgeable Local Indianapolis, IN Agents

A licensed Indianapolis, IN New Western agent specializes in working with investors and delivers residential investment properties that meet your unique investing and exit strategies.

Less Hassle Sourcing Indianapolis, IN Properties

Our Indianapolis, IN New Western agents work behind the scenes to eliminate problems, deliver a marketable title and provide a fast, seamless process to close. Gain access to vetted opportunities without hours of research, phone calls, and door-knocking.

Why Choose New Western in Indianapolis, IN

We buy and sell a property every 13 minutes for over 200,000 investors looking for rehabs to fix-and-flip or fix-and-rent in our marketplace. We are adding new properties in the Indianapolis, IN area daily. Join the New Western marketplace and locate your next investment opportunity in Indianapolis, IN.

We source properties all over the Indianapolis, IN area

Previously Sold Properties

a red car parked in front of a houseIndianapolis, IN
Purchase Price: $67,000.00
Resold Price: $120,000.00
a couple of houses that are next to each otherIndianapolis, IN
Purchase Price: $89,000.00
Resold Price: $190,000.00
a house with snow on the ground and steps leading up to itIndianapolis, IN
Purchase Price: $104,547.00
Resold Price: $200,000.00
a blue building with a clock tower on top of itIndianapolis, IN
Purchase Price: $102,000.00
Resold Price: $200,000.00
a house with a car parked in front of itIndianapolis, IN
Purchase Price: $180,000.00
Resold Price: $280,000.00

Experiences from people just like you

Macario E.
San Antonio, TX

New Western gave me an opportunity to buy property on Day One and now, because of them, I quit my job and became a successful, full-time investor. It’s changed my life. And now I’m able to control my life and work for myself. I built a team around me and a name that I stand behind now. But it all started with New Western.


How do I gain access to your inventory?

After an initial virtual or in-person onboarding meeting, you will have access to our vast inventory of properties. The New Western agent will explain in detail how our properties are sold and how the transactions will be structured during that initial meeting.

Why do I need to have a call with a New Western agent to get access to the buyer's list?

A New Western agent is involved in the entire transaction process from search to executing contracts and closing. To get the most out of your search for a deal, we need to know what type of properties, neighborhoods, and local markets you’re interested in and your investment goals and strategies.

Can I use traditional bank financing to purchase your properties?

New Western inventory can’t typically be purchased using traditional bank financing due to the condition of the property, the timeline of closing, and the overall structure of the transaction. These properties need to be purchased with cash or a lending program specifically designed for rehab purposes, such as a hard money loan or private financing. Check with the local agent for approved financial options.

Can you use a rehab loan to purchase a property?

Certain ones, yes. You can use a hard money loan to purchase our properties. Check with a local agent for approved financial options.

Does New Western provide financing?

No, New Western does not provide financing. However, we can easily connect you with numerous lenders on Sherman Bridge, a lending marketplace partner that will guide you through the process of selecting the best lender to suit your investment strategies.

How much cash do I need to buy a house?

It depends. Factors that influence how much cash you need include the market, the lender and the degree of work the distressed property requires. Investors need a down payment to purchase the property, money left in reserve for carrying costs (like interest, taxes and insurance) and enough capital to repair the property.

Do I need a real estate agent involved to purchase your properties?

No, you don’t need a licensed agent to purchase a property from us.. However, you are free to employ a third-party agent to represent you (at your cost) if you choose.

Get access to our curated inventory of investor friendly properties

Disclaimer: New Western is a licensed real estate brokerage that provides investors access to its marketplace of investment properties. The information provided here does not and is not intended to constitute legal, financial, tax, or real estate investing advice. New Western represents the seller in any resulting transaction and is not acting as an agent of the investor or any potential buyer in any resulting real estate transaction. The content published herein is provided “as-is” for informational purposes only. No representations are made that the content is error-free, and New Western does not make any representations or warranties as to the effectiveness of any investment strategy. This website does not create any warranty, contractual obligation, or agency relationship between any investor or potential buyer and New Western. New Western does not and cannot guarantee the accuracy of any information that was prepared by an unaffiliated third party. Buying real estate and engaging in real estate transactions involves varying degrees of risk, and investors and potential buyers should educate themselves on the potential risks by consulting their own legal counsel, CPA, tax consultant, or licensed real estate agent. No discussion with any New Western employee, agent, or representative serves as the receipt of or substitute for personalized advice from a professional retained by investor.